Tweeting into an internet storm over “cancel culture,” Ocasio-Cortez informed those who think they have been censured for their opinions they are probably “just being challenged, held accountable, or unliked.”
According to Ocasio-Cortez, a New York Democrat, the real victims of “cancel culture” are left-wing activists — and her.The term “cancel culture” comes from entitlement - as though the person complaining has the right to a large, captive audience,& one is a victim if people choose to tune them out.
— Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (@AOC) July 10, 2020
Odds are you’re not actually cancelled, you’re just being challenged, held accountable, or unliked.
The trigger: Ocasio-Cortez was responding to an open letter published on Tuesday in Harper’s Magazine that warned against a spreading culture of “censoriousness.”Many of the people actually “cancelled” are those long denied a fair hearing of their ideas to begin w/:
— Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (@AOC) July 10, 2020
Palestinian human rights advocates
Abolitionists
Anticapitalists
Anti-imperialists
Not spicy “contrarians” who want to play devils advocate w/ your basic rights in the NYT
- The mini-manifesto was signed by 150 mostly left-leaning luminaries, including J.K. Rowling, Gloria Steinem, Malcolm Gladwell and Noam Chomsky.
Many other members of the social justice left — where “cancel culture” has long been downplayed or denied — joined Ocasio-Cortez in condemning the letter and its signatories as privileged and out of touch.
- Some tried to make the debate about race and gender or suggested nefarious motives.
Ygelsias, a reformed “cancel culture” denier, declined to comment other than voicing support for VanDerWerff.I sent a version of this to the editors of Vox. (I have redacted some bits that are internal to Vox and shouldn’t be aired publicly.) pic.twitter.com/splNNSMivd
— Emily VanDerWerff 😎 (@emilyvdw) July 7, 2020
- He seemed to imply on Twitter that Vox was silencing him.
- Other prominent liberals boasted they had declined to sign in the first place.
The defense: Writer Thomas Chatterton Williams, who spearheaded the Harper’s letter, said the reaction proved his point.Okay, I did not sign THE LETTER when I was asked 9 days ago because I could see in 90 seconds that it was fatuous, self-important drivel that would only troll the people it allegedly was trying to reach -- and I said as much
— Richard Kim (@RichardKimNYC) July 7, 2020
“The very few people distancing themselves from the letter have been pressured and shamed to do so, not because of the arguments in the text, but because of the presence of certain other signatories, which I think is all the more reason the document is necessary,” he told TheWrap on Thursday.
Chatterton Williams, who was raised black but later rejected race, said he sought “as wide and diverse a range of signatories as we could feasibly get.”
- Contrary to claims by Ocasio-Cortez and other critics, many transgender, female and non-white people ended up signing the letter.
- And two of the signatories, Salman Rushie and Garry Kasparov, were hunted by authoritarian regimes because of their ideas.
Conservative commentators generally agreed the letter was a good if flawed corrective to left-wing intolerance and the backlash was bad.Garry Kasparov was forced out of Russia
— Anne Applebaum (@anneapplebaum) July 7, 2020
Seth Mandel, the Washington Examiner’s editor-in-chief, declared Ocasio-Cortez’s Twitter thread to be “the worst take” of all.
Actor James Woods was characteristically brutal in a tweet on Friday.Right on schedule with the worst take pic.twitter.com/hURPgum3Bk
— Seth Mandel (@SethAMandel) July 10, 2020
Amid a racial upheaval across the United States in recent weeks, several dozen people have been fired over often-dubious allegations of racism or racial insensitivity.You and your mob have been destroying careers and reputations and livelihoods on a whim. Now you’re being hoist by your own petard. Those of us blacklisted, libeled, and falsely maligned have zero sympathy. You all started it. May you be devoured by it. https://t.co/PGzMzNa0ku
— James Woods (@RealJamesWoods) July 10, 2020